|
re:看了一下午儿童文学作品的书单,觉得黑暗的...
看了一下午儿童文学作品的书单,觉得黑暗的东西太多,真的适合现在的孩子读么?
我小时候最喜欢看的是《小马过河》,最不喜欢看的是高尔基三部曲小人书,还有就是著名童话们,都有让我做噩梦的经历。
现在的动画片喜庆多了,比如喜洋洋灰太郎。 可是文学读物给人的感觉,好像如果喜庆了,就得不了奖,所以大家还是往深沉里写。
举个例子,The Tale of Despereaux (2003) (有电影,没看过)
作者Kate DiCamillo,著名儿童文学作家,得过大奖,还写过 Because of Winn-Dixie (2000), The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane (2006)
都是小学高年级读物,我都没看过,只知道大都不喜欢看,为啥也不说。
今天去读了一下 Amazon 上的评语,几乎所有成人都评价作者故事写的好,语言优美,唯一的问题就是有不宜于儿童的情节,有个别孩子写的,说老师上课选这本书做精读,全班没人喜欢。 Because of Winn-Dixie 好像好一点,The Tale of Despereaux 感觉最不好,不过这是金奖作品。 The Tale of Despereaux 下面的一段 review:
This is a terrible, terrible book. It is very dark and filled with characters who are abusive and abused, lonely, sad, violent, and depressed. I read the entire novel because I wanted to have faith in it and wanted to believe that it would get better. It didn't. The subsequent animated film was no better. I read it out loud to my 7-year-old. He liked it alright, but didn't get excited about it. I'm sort of sorry I read it to him, given how dark and negative it is. Think twice about this one.
孩子需要看什么样的书,接着糊涂。。。
|
|