请推荐鱼油

xwm96

我们用KIRKMAN的COD LIVER OIL，编号为822/8。同时我们用KIRKMAN NU－THERA WITH P5P WITHOUT A &D，编号为048/300。

施丹

Meanwhile

我的孩子以前开始吃带P5P的复合维生素时，显得特别多动，我认识的几个孩子也是这样。昨天我从下Kiekman的网页上看到，P5P会引起多动，如果吃P5P会引起你的孩子多动的话，应该换用不含P5P的产品。



Meanwhile

xwm96

承昊妈妈，

就你提的问题，我咨询了WILLISS。他认为NORDIC NATURALS COD LOVER OIL不KIRKMAN的CLO胶囊更适合小孩，因为其含EPA、DHA。他认为若每日日晒不足，可以额外不Vd。而且，KIRKMAN参照一般医生推荐的用量,通常会比较低。他认为4岁或以上的儿童用10，000IU/天的Va是安全的。

以下是他给我回复的邮件，仅供参考。

       

收件人:        shid/HW/minmetals

抄送:       

       

主题:        Re: Fm Shi Dan



Dearest Dan:



> Dear Williss,

> I attach below information on Kirkman CLO and Nordic Naturals Arctic CLO

> from Kirkmanlabs website. As suggested by you Baobao takes 5

> teaspoons (9575IU Va, 100IU Vd) every day together with Zinc at an empty

> stomach before bedtime. Some other parents are also considering using

> Nu-thera with P5P without A&D and get Va&Vd from CLO. But they reminded

> that Vd from Nordic Naturals Arctic CLO (which we bought last time and is

> going to be used up, contain Vd 20IU) may not be enough, as Nu-thera with

> P5P

> with Va&Vd contained Va2500IU and Vd 200IU. They ask if Kirkmans CLO should

> be used instead, which contains more Vd(250-300IU).



The various labels can be confusing as is the differences between capsules

and oils. Kirkman's capsules are not cod-liver oil per se, but are vitamin

A/D capsules, that is to say, the vitamins have been concentrated from CLO,

but the product is not CLO. Additionally, the capsule, in my experience

prevents the effectiveness of the vitamin A. We don't want Kirkman's vitamin

A capsules, but we want the oil. If we use Kirkman Brand CLO, it has more

vitamin A in it, so we have to limit the amount used, and thus limit the

amount of EPA/DHA, which is minimal (250 mg) to begin with. Nordic Naturals

best meet the needs of the children. Yes, it has less vitamin D in it, and if

your child is not allowed in the sun, then you need an additional vitamin D

only supplement. Best, allow your child in the sun every day. Use Nordic

Natural and put the child in the sun. Don't worry about sun-screen, it is

probably toxic to a PST child anyway.



>I find the recommended  usages under the attached doc are much lower than we

> take, and Kirkmans CLO

> do not contain EPA &DHA. The liquid form contains Ve, but quantity of Ve

> contained is not mentioned. Some parents also asked whether 10,000IU Va is

> too much as those in Nu-thera with Va is only 2500IU.

> Looking forward to your suggestions and comments.



The medical profession has been taught that vitamin A will kill you :-(, so

they recommend 1/3 tsp or some small amount that did help, but is not what

the child needs. Especially if he has "Chicken-skin" bumps on shoulders,

arms, thighs, and calves. Kirkman recommends what the doctors are

recommending, but that is not enough. Anything under 10,000 IU is safe for a

child 4 years old or more in my humble opinion. Younger ones may reduce that

a bit, but vitamin A can be taken in very high amounts for as much as 3

months with only good reported (no more infections). If your child has

measles in the gut, he probably needs more than 10,000 IU.



> Many thanks.

>

Loving you, Dear Friend,



Willis