|
re:Programs for stage t...
Programs for stage two
Role-play activities
In stage two of friendship, children develop greater cooperation when playing with their peers and develop more constructive means of dealing with conflict. It is important that the child with Asperger's syndrome learns the theory of, and gains practice in, various aspects of cooperative play using Social Stories™ and role-play activities. These can provide practice in aspects of cooperative play such as giving and receiving compliments, accepting suggestions, working towards a common goal, being aware of personal body space, proximity and touch, coping with and giving criticism, and recognizing signs of boredom, embarrassment and frustration and when and how to interrupt. The role-play and modelling of aspects of social interaction such as giving compliments can be recorded on video to provide practice and constructive feedback (Apple, Billingsley and Schwartz 2005).
In situations of conflict or disagreement, the child with Asperger's syndrome will need encouragement to seek an adult as an adjudicator, rather than act as the person to determine who is at fault and administer the consequences. Social Stories™ and role-play activities can focus on aspects such as the benefits of negotiation and compromise, being fair and the importance of an apology. Issues of control can be a problem. If the child has a tendency to be autocratic or dominant, or to use threats and aggression to achieve his or her goal, other approaches can be explained and encouraged. You are more likely to get what you want by being nice to someone.
A teacher assistant in the classroom and playground
To facilitate successful social inclusion in the classroom and playground, the child will probably need support staff at school. A teacher assistant can observe the child's social behaviour, particularly behaviours indicative of age-appropriate friendship skills, and provide immediate positive feedback and guidance. The teacher assistant has a number of functions including:
. helping the child identify the relevant social cues and responses
. providing individual tuition using specific activities or games, role-play, rehearsal and writing Social Stories™ with the child
. encouraging other children to successfully include the child with Asperger's syndrome in their play
. providing guidance in managing potential conflict between the child with Asperger's syndrome and peers
. providing positive feedback for the child.
The number of hours in the school day that a child with Asperger's syndrome needs a teacher assistant will vary according to the abilities of the child, the social context and abilities of the peer group.
Playing, with dolls or figures and reading fiction
In stage two of friendship, I have noted that there can be different coping mechanisms used by girls with Asperger's syndrome in comparison to boys. Girls with Asperger's syndrome are more likely to be interested observers of the social play of other girls and to imitate their play at home using dolls and imaginary friends, or adopt the persona of a socially able girl. These activities can be a valuable opportunity to analyse and rehearse friendship skills.
Girls with Asperger's syndrome can develop a special interest in reading fiction. This also provides an insight into thoughts, emotions and social relationships. A boy with Asperger's syndrome can be encouraged to play with figures, usually masculine action heroes, but to re-enact everyday experiences rather than movies, and to read fiction, perhaps based on a special interest - for example, a book such as The Railway Children if the child is interested in trains.
Shared interests
One of the common replies of typical children at this stage in the development of friendship to the question 'What makes a good friend?' is 'We like the same things.' Shared interests are a basis for friendship. I know a child with Asperger's syndrome who had a remarkable interest in and knowledge of insects, especially ants. His peers tolerated his enthusiasm and monologues on ants, but he was not regarded as a potential friend as there was a limit to their enthusiasm for the topic. He was learning friendship skills such as how to have a reciprocal conversation, waiting for the other person to finish what he or she was saying, and how to give and receive compliments and show empathy. When he used these social skills with his class peers, they were achieved by intellectual effort and guidance and perceived by other children as somewhat contrived and artificial. He had few genuine friends.
By chance, another child with Asperger's syndrome lived close by, and also had an interest in ants. Their parents arranged a meeting of the two young entomologists; when they met, the social rapport between the new friends was remarkable. The two boys became regular companions on ant safaris, shared knowledge and resources on insects, made a joint ant study and regularly contacted each other with long and genuinely reciprocal conversations about their latest ant-related discoveries. When observing their interactions, it was clear that there was a natural balance to the conversation, with both children being able to wait patiently, listen attentively, show empathy and give compliments at a level not observed when they were with their typical peers.
Parents and teachers can consider friendship matchmaking, based on the child's special interest. Local parent support groups for families with a child with Asperger's syndrome can provide the names and addresses of families, along with the special interests of the children, in order to arrange a potentially successful friendship. However, I have noted that when the shared interest ends for one partner, the friendship may also end.
The interest can also be used to facilitate friendship with typical peers. My wife's sister has Asperger's syndrome and an outstanding ability in art. She wrote that at school:
Longing to make friends, when someone complimented a drawing I had done, I started giving people drawings until someone accused me of bragging - a rebuke I never forgot. I was only trying to win friendship. (Personal communication)
If the child with Asperger's syndrome has a particular talent such as drawing, a teacher can arrange for the child to form a working partnership with another child whose abilities are complementary. For example, the artist may become the illustrator for a child whose talent is writing stories. This can demonstrate the value of collaboration and teamwork.
Sense of humour
Another reply to the question 'What makes a good friend?' can be 'Someone with a sense of humour'. Children with Asperger's syndrome tend to make a literal interpretation of what someone says and may not understand when someone is joking; however, there can be a wonderful, though sometimes idiosyncratic, sense of humour (Darlington 2001). The very young child may laugh at the way a word is spoken and repeat the word to himself as a very private Joke, but the reason for the humour is not explained or shared. The development of humour can progress to the creation of inventive puns, word associations and word play (Werth, Perkins and Boucher 2001). The next developmental stage of humour can be visual slapstick as occurs in the comedy programmes of Mr Bean and subsequently, at an earlier age than expected, an interest in surreal humour such as the comedy style of Monty Python.
Among peers, the jokes of children between the ages six and nine years can start to include laughter associated with rude words and actions. Other children will be aware of the nature of the Joke, an appropriate context for it, and who would appreciate it. The child with Asperger's syndrome may repeat a rude joke to be popular in circumstances when other children would realize it would not be funny. The joke that causes uproarious laughter among children in the playground is not necessarily the joke to tell your grandmother at the lunch table on Sunday The child may need a Social Story™ to explain why some jokes are funny for some people and not others.
Hans Asperger wrote that children with Asperger's syndrome lack a sense of humour but this is not consistent with my experience of several thousand children with Asperger's syndrome. Many have a unique or alternative perspective on life that can be the basis of comments that are perceptive and clearly humorous. I agree with Claire Sainsbury when she writes, 'It is not a sense of humour we lack, but rather the social skills to recognize when others are joking, signal that we ourselves are joking, or appreciate jokes which rely on an understanding of social conventions' (Sainsbury 2000, p.80).
Some adolescents with Asperger's syndrome can be remarkably imaginative in creating original humour and jokes but the topic is often related to the special interest and may not be created to share the laughter with others (Lyons and Fitzgerald 2004; Werth et al. 2001). I know many teenagers with Asperger's syndrome who create abundant jokes, although sometimes I am not sure what I am supposed to be laughing at. However, the laughter of the person with Asperger's syndrome in response to an idiosyncratic joke is very infectious.
Concentric circles
The child with Asperger's syndrome will probably need guidance in the understanding of the different social hierarchies and social conventions for humour, topics of conversation, touch and personal body space, greetings and gestures of affection. I use an activity where a series of concentric circles are drawn on a very large sheet of paper. In the inner circle is written the name of the child and immediate family members. In the surrounding circle are written the names of people well known to the child but not immediate family, such as his or her teacher, aunts and uncles, neighbours and the child's friends. The next circle, closer to the perimeter, can include the names of family friends and acquaintances, distant relatives and children who are known to the child but are not friends. The next circle can include people known but seen only occasionally, such as a doctor or the person who delivers the mail. The outer circle can include people who are initially strangers or seen rarely, such as the distant relative.
Once the circles and occupants of the circles have been agreed, the topic of conversation is an aspect of social behaviour such as different types of greetings. The adult facilitating the activity can work with the child on finding and cutting out pictures of different types of greetings from magazines. The discussion centres around deciding in which circle to place each greeting. A handshake may be an appropriate greeting for the doctor but not the expected greeting for a grandma. The child may really like and admire his or her teachers but giving them a hug and kiss each morning would not be an age-appropriate greeting for a seven-year-old to give a teacher. An alternative affectionate but verbal greeting can be suggested. The concentric circles activity can become more intriguing for older children when considering the greetings of people from different cultures. In northern Europe, the greeting of female friends can be just a smile, but in France, the expectation is a kiss on each cheek. In New Zealand Maori culture, sticking out one's tongue at a respected guest is a traditional form of welcome. However, a parent may have to explain that if the family do not live in New Zealand, sticking out one's tongue is generally not an acceptable greeting.
The concentric circles activity can also be used with programs on friendship to illustrate many of the rules and different aspects of friendship. For example, it is a very clear way of explaining how someone may 'cross the boundaries' and move from being an acquaintance to being a close friend. The great advantage of the concentric circles activity is that it enables the child to visualize a range of complex social conventions and to know what to say and do when socializing with someone within one of the designated circles,
What not to say
Children with Asperger's syndrome are usually brutally honest and speak their mind. Their allegiance is to the truth, not people's feelings. They may have to learn not to tell the truth all the time. While honesty is a virtue, peers at this stage are starling to tell white lies so as not to hurt friends' feelings, or to express solidarity and allegiance to friendship by not informing an adult of the misbehaviour of a friend. Such behaviour may appear immoral and illogical for a child with Asperger's syndrome, who is willing to inform the teacher 'who did it' and that a friend has made a stupid mistake. This is not a recommended way to make or keep friends - The child with Asperger's syndrome may benefit from Social Stories™ to understand why it is appropriate at times to say something that is not the truth, and when to stay quiet.
An anthropologist in the classroom
One way to describe a person with Asperger's syndrome is someone who comes from a different culture and has a different way of perceiving and thinking about the world. Some adults with Asperger's syndrome have suggested that the term Asperger's syndrome should be replaced with 'wrong planet' syndrome- Clare Sainsbury, an Oxford university graduate who has Asperger's syndrome, has written a book entitled Martian in the Playground (2000) to help parents and teachers understand Asperger's syndrome. The conceptualization of someone with Asperger's syndrome as being from a different culture or planet can help change the attitudes of adults and peers, but can also be used to substantiate an intervention strategy.
The child with Asperger's syndrome is trying to understand our social customs in much the same way as an anthropologist who has discovered a new tribe will want to study its people and customs. The anthropologist will need someone from that culture to explain the culture, customs and language. A teacher or teaching assistant assigned to the child with Asperger's syndrome can take the role of a guide to explain this new culture or civilization. The process is one of discovery and explanation of the reason for particular customs. A visitor to a new culture will need a guidebook, and writing Social Stories™ is a collaboration between the guide (teacher) and anthropologist (child). Teenagers and adults with Asperger's syndrome would certainly benefit from writing or reading a travel guide to understanding and living with typical people, or, to use a term created by adults with Asperger's syndrome, neurotypicals.
The representative of the culture, or personal guide, can sit with the anthropologist in a corner of the classroom or playground and both watch, comment and make notes on the social interactions of the children, with the guide providing an explanatory commentary. Another activity is the game of 'spot the friendly act', taking turns to identify an act of friendship. The guide comments on why the particular behaviour is considered friendly or not friendly. A people-watching game, with a guide, can provide information on friendship without the child with Asperger's syndrome feeling that he or she is the centre of attention, or the person who inevitably makes mistakes.
After-school social experiences
Children with Asperger's syndrome work twice as hard at school as their peers, as they are learning both the academic and the social curriculum. Unlike other children, they are using cognitive abilities rather than intuition to socialize and make friends. As explained by Stephen, Tt takes all my brain power to be a friend.' At the end of the school day, the child has usually had enough social experiences and desperately needs to relax in solitude. As far as the child with Asperger's syndrome is concerned, friendships end at the school gate. The child can therefore resist parents' suggestions to contact friends from school or play with neighbourhood children. He or she has had enough socializing at school, and parents may need to accept that the child does not have the energy or motivation to socialize any more. If parents arrange social experiences, it is important that the experiences are brief, structured, supervised, successful and voluntary.
Social skills groups
There has been some success reported in the research literature for social skills groups for children, adolescents and young adults with Asperger's syndrome (Andron and Weber 1998; Barnhill et al. 2002; Barry et al. 2003; Bauminger 2002; Broderick et al. 2002; Howlin and Yates 1999; Marriage, Gordon and Brand 1995; Mesibov 1984; Ozonoff and Miller 1995; Soloman, Goodlin-Jones and Anders 2004; Williams 1989). The group members receive information on why certain skills are important, and practise applying those skills using modelling, role-play, reviewing video recordings and receiving constructive feedback from the group leader and fellow participants. The programs have focused on conversation skills, reading and interpreting body language, understanding the perspective of others and friendship skills. A variation on this approach, focusing on the development of emotional intelligence, has been conducted by Andron and Weber (1998), who have coordinated social skills groups using family members, especially siblings, as participants. Their curriculum emphasizes the development of appropriate affect or emotions in social situations.
At present it is extremely difficult to determine whether social skills groups are an effective means of improving the social integration skills of children with Asperger's syndrome. Outcome measures have primarily been qualitative and we do not know if this technique can change specific skills in natural settings. Nevertheless, experience has shown that the groups are perceived as valuable by parents, teachers and participants- In particular, the participants have appreciated the opportunity to meet people similar to themselves who share the same confusion and experiences. This can be the basis of subsequent friendships and self-help groups.
Programs for peers
The other children in the class of the child with Asperger's syndrome will need explanations and guidance in understanding and encouraging the friendship abilities of their classmate. Such children will know that the child with Asperger's syndrome does not play or interact with them in the same way as other children. Without guidance and support from the teacher, the reaction to the child with Asperger's syndrome can be rejection and ridicule rather than acceptance and inclusion in their activities. As much as we have programs to help the child with Asperger's syndrome integrate with his or her peers, the other children need their own programs. They will need to know how to respond to behaviours that appear unfriendly and how to encourage abilities that facilitate friendships - A successful interaction requires a constructive commitment from both parties, and a teacher will need to be a good role model of what to do, and should commend other children who adapt to, welcome and support the child with Asperger's syndrome.The peer group may need their own equivalent of Social Stories™ to improve mutual understanding and to be encouraged to provide guidance for the child with Asperger's syndrome when the teacher is not present or available.
Stage three of friendship - 9 to 13 years
In the third stage in the development of friendships there is a distinct gender split in the choice of friends and companions, and a friend is defined not simply as someone who helps but as someone who is carefully chosen because of special personality attributes. A friend is someone who genuinely cares with complementary attitudes, ideas and values. There is a growing need for companionship and greater selectivity and durability in the friendship alliances. There is a strong desire to be liked by peers and a mutual sharing of experiences and thoughts rather than toys.
With an increase in self-disclosure there is the recognition of the importance of being trustworthy and a tendency to seek advice not only for practical problems but also for interpersonal issues. Friends support each other in terms of repairing each other's emotions. If children are sad, close friends will cheer them up, or if angry, calm them down, to prevent them from getting into trouble.
Friends and the peer group become increasingly important in strengthening or destroying self-esteem and determining what is appropriate social behaviour. Peer-group acceptance and values can override the opinion of parents. The power of the peer group can become greater than the power of adults.
When conflicts occur, friends will now use more effective repair mechanisms. Arguments can be less 'heated', with reduced confrontation and more disengagement, admission of mistakes and recognition that it is not simply a matter of winner and loser. A satisfactory resolution of interpersonal conflict between friends can actually strengthen the relationship. The friend is forgiven and the conflict is put in perspective. These qualities of interpersonal skills that are played out in friendships are the foundation of interpersonal skills for adult relationships.
Programs for stage three
Same-gender friendships
In stage three of friendship, there is usually a clear gender preference in the choice of friends and associates. The activities and interests of boys, who may be playing team games or seasonal sports, may be considered of little interest to boys with Asperger's syndrome. They are also likely to be less able than male peers to understand team games, and clumsy with regard to ball skills, dexterity and coordination. Will Hadcroft explained in his autobiography that:
I was frightened of the other boys, and this was very apparent to them. Tackling was a nightmare, and I let the ball go without much of a fight, to the fury of my fellow team members. (Hadcroft 2005, p.62)
The boy with Asperger's syndrome knows that he is usually the last person chosen for a team and can be actively shunned and alienated from potential male friends.
When the boy with Asperger's syndrome is alone in the playground, he is likely to be approached by one of two groups: the predatory males who seek someone socially isolated, vulnerable and gullible to tease and torment (see Chapter 4); or girls, who feel sorry for the boy because of his apparent loneliness, and offer inclusion and support in their activities and games. While other boys at this age would usually shun girls, using derogatory and sexist remarks, he can be recruited into the play of girls and actively welcomed. If the boy with Asperger's syndrome is unsure what to do when socializing with girls, his female friends are more likely to be supportive than critical - 'He's a boy so he wouldn't understand, so I'll help him.' There can be the development of genuine 'opposite-gender' friendships.
Having opposite-gender friends at this stage of friendship can have two consequences for boys with Asperger's syndrome; further alienation from boys who consider he is 'fraternizing with the enemy', and absorption within the female culture through imitation, resulting in the development of feminine body language, vocal characteristics and interests. The child may enjoy and benefit from the friendships with girls, but other boys may taunt him as being more like a girl, often using the description 'gay' as an insult. The boy may feel that the only gender to accept and understand him is female - his mother, perhaps his sisters, and his female friends, which could contribute to gender-identity problems.
|
|